The emphasis throughout is on making the key ideas and results as clear as possible, which involves some simplifications. So concepts such as integrated assessment models, externalities, discount rates, carbon prices, tipping points and cost-benefit analyses are introduced only as necessary, and explained in context. And Nordhaus presents broad conclusions without working through the details. (None of the economics involved is controversial, however, and where there is uncertainty or debate he makes that clear.) The result is that The Climate Casino should be quite broadly accessible. It would be a challenge for a reader with no experience of thinking about economics, but not an impossible one.
In a way climate change starts with economics and Nordhaus, whose own research is focused in this area, begins by looking at likely future greenhouse emissions under various models for economic growth, carbon intensity and so forth. A large uncertainty here comes from not being able to predict changes in technology. He goes on to give a brief summary of the climate science, looking at the predictions for the next century or so, and to introduce the possibility of climate tipping points, fairly abrupt transitions which are irreversible in the short-term.
Next comes a survey of the likely impacts of climate change on agriculture, health, oceans, hurricane intensity, and biodiversity. Adding up the damages from these suggests the total costs will be small relative to expected changes in economic activity over the next century, but there is considerable uncertainty and the impacts are concentrated in unmanaged, non-market areas where the uncertainties are highest.
Responding to these impacts will involve adaptation (making changes to economies and societies) and possibly geoengineering, but there are limits to those and mitigation (reducing carbon emissions) will remain a central part of any response. Nordhaus presents estimates of the costs associated with this, from both economic and engineering perspectives, and explains the importance of discounting future costs.
An overview of international policy history is followed by an explanation of the necessity of some kind of cost-benefit analysis and an illustration of the global balance between the costs of mitigation and the costs of climate change. Nordhaus explains how carbon prices work and why they are essential for a response flexible enough to cope with the complexities and uncertainties of economies and technologies. At a national level, he explains the advantages and disadvantages of carbon taxes and cap-and-trade systems. Internationally, he argues that a harmonised minimum carbon price will be easier to negotiate, and to maintain, than a cap-and-trade system such as Kyoto.
The "second best" alternatives to trading systems mostly involve regulation — of say car fuel efficiency — and are very much less efficient, sometimes even counter-productive. (The presence of "energy-cost myopia", where consumers don't fully value savings from energy efficiency improvements, may provide justification for regulation on other grounds.) Governments have an important role in supporting research and development of new technology in areas such as energy efficiency, but appropriate carbon pricing will also help here.
A final section looks at "climate politics", with chapters on criticisms of climate science, public opinion, and obstacles to policies addressing climate change. This is perhaps the most US-centric part of The Climate Casino.
Despite the subtitle, Nordhaus doesn't really attempt to convey the uncertainty of the climate science. To give just one example, he includes a pair of figures showing projected sea level rise through 2100 and 2500, for unconstrained and temperature-limited emission scenarios, which don't indicate any of the uncertainty from climate models or ice-sheet dynamics. Given the economic focus in The Climate Casino this is a reasonable simplification — and Nordhaus does consider, more abstractly, tipping points and "unknown unknowns". The casino metaphor is also stretched a bit far — at one point Nordhaus has to resort to having us imagine a roulette wheel with an unknown numbers of slots and unknown bad consequences on getting a 0! — but it's not clear that there is a better alternative.
Minor quibbles aside, The Climate Casino is a clearly presented introduction to an important topic. It will appeal to a broad audience, but it really should be read by politicians responsible for climate change policy.
- External links:
- buy from Amazon.com or Amazon.co.uk
- buy from Wordery
- share this review on Facebook or Twitter